Prior to the 1935 vote, the Brimfield Public Library was funded by subscriptions and fundraising efforts such as card parties.

In April 1935, residents approved a tax of $.0005 on all taxable property in the Village of Brimfield to provide a fund for the maintenance of the Brimfield Public Library. After the tax levy was approved, library supporters continued to host fundraising events to supplement the tax income.

Families living outside the village could purchase a card for .25 cents per year