On March 18, 1927, Brimfield community members met to discuss the formation of a Public Library Association. The Association was formally created on March 31, 1927. Miss Florence Wyman was elected President, and Mrs. Bertha A. Roberts was elected secretary. Other association members included Mrs. H. O. Cady, Mrs. Orvill Tucker, Mrs. Homer Tucker, Mrs. Fred Walliker, Mr. D. H. Johnson, and Mr. O. F. Kelly.

The Library was originally referred to as the Brimfield Community Library.